Opting Out Of Organ Donation

Nic Zumaran
bioedge.org
2019-05-12

Legislation that presumes consent for organ donation passed unanimously in Nova Scotia last month, making the Canadian province the first jurisdiction in North America with an opt-out law. However, the act will not come into effect for another 12 to 18 months to allow time for planning, public education and training for health-care workers.

Dr Stephen Beed, the head of Nova Scotia’s transplant program, told a legislature committee that within five years of the implementation Nova Scotia would see a 30% to 50% increase in organ donations.

However, there are some ethical questions which hang over opt-out policies. Whilst an increase in the number of organs available for transplant is a worthy aim, the changes to legislation pose concerns regarding informed consent.

Disseminating the right information about health is not as straightforward as it seems. Government health campaigns can fall short of delivering comprehensive information. For example, measles outbreaks continue despite campaigns aimed at correcting false beliefs about vaccinations and similarly application of MAID (medical assisted dying) legislation remains unclear to the general public and health professionals alike.

Full Text

More Headlines…